Serving as the executor of an estate is not just an administrative duty. It involves significant legal responsibilities, particularly when it comes to ensuring that all tax obligations of the deceased are properly addressed. Executors must locate the estate’s assets, assess debts and liabilities, and make distributions to beneficiaries. Critically, they must do all this while complying with federal tax laws. Failure to satisfy estate tax for example, can result in personal liability for unpaid tax, even if the executor lacked bad faith.
Executor’s Personal Liability For Unpaid Estate Taxes
The U.S. estate tax is a separate and distinct tax liability assessed on the transfer of the decedent’s assets at death. It is not an “income” tax, but a “transfer” tax. This transfer tax is asserted against the estate of the individual who passed away, not against the recipient of the inheritance or bequest. Estate tax is assessed on the value of property in the decedent’s estate and applies differently to U.S. versus non-U.S. decedents.
Executors can be held personally liable for unpaid estate taxes under a strict liability standard. This risk is grounded in both the Internal Revenue Code and the Federal Claims Priority Act. These rules establish that an executor who makes distributions from the estate before satisfying estate tax liability may become personally liable for the unpaid estate tax. Importantly, this liability does not require the executor to have knowledge of the tax owed. The mere act of distributing assets, for example, to estate beneficiaries before settling the tax debt can trigger personal liability if the IRS is unable to collect the tax from the estate.
Beware – “Accidental” Executors Liable for Estate Tax
Under IRC Section 2203, the term “executor” means “the executor or administrator of the decedent, or, if there is no executor or administrator appointed, qualified, and acting within the United States, then any person in actual or constructive possession of any property of the decedent.”
When a U.S. executor is not appointed, who can be treated as an executor under this broad definition will come as a surprise. Relevant Treasury Regulations clarify that such statutory executors can include, among others, the decedent’s agents and representatives, safe-deposit companies, warehouse companies, and other custodians of property in the U.S., brokers holding, as collateral, securities belonging to the decedent, and U.S. debtors of the decedent.
How can it happen that an executor is not appointed to administer the estate of a deceased individual? Here are a few examples: If all assets are owned jointly with survivor rights, these assets will pass outside of probate and thus no executor will be appointed for the estate. In such an instance the statutory “executor” would include a joint owner of the property. Similarly, an accidental executor can be the trustee of a revocable trust after the grantor has passed away. In many cases, the estate of a nonresident alien decedent will not have an executor appointed in the U.S. to deal with U.S.-situs assets. This means that other parties will be treated as the executor for tax purposes, and this can include heirs of the decedent’s estate.
In these cases, while not officially appointed as executors, each of the parties will meet the tax law definition since each will be “in actual or constructive possession of any property of the decedent.” Once treated as an estate “executor”, they will have potential personal liability for any unpaid estate tax. For this reason, savvy brokerage firms and other financial institutions will not release assets to the heirs without assurance from the IRS (usually in the form of a Federal Transfer Certificate) that estate taxes have been paid.
Executor Liability for Decedent’s Unpaid Income Or Gift Taxes
Personal liability for the decedent’s unpaid income or gift taxes is governed by a more nuanced standard. While the FCPA still applies, the trigger for liability is different. Courts have consistently held that an executor may be held personally liable for a decedent’s unpaid income or gift taxes only if two conditions are met:
1. The executor had actual or constructive knowledge of the decedent’s tax liability; and
2. The executor distributed estate assets to other creditors or beneficiaries before paying the government.
In such cases, personal liability arises from a failure to prioritize the government’s claim when the executor knew or should have known of its existence. Unlike estate tax liability, which can attach strictly upon asset distribution, liability for income or gift taxes hinges on fault or negligence.
Preventive Measures Using IRS Forms
To minimize personal exposure, executors should notify the IRS of their fiduciary role by filing IRS Form 56 (Notice Concerning Fiduciary Relationship). Although not mandatory, this form ensures IRS correspondence will reach the executor at the correct address. The same form should also be used to notify the IRS when the fiduciary relationship ends and all duties as administrator of the estate have been completed.
Executors concerned about possible outstanding income or gift tax liabilities of the decedent can request a prompt assessment by filing IRS Form 4810 (Request for Prompt Assessment for Income and Gift Taxes). This will shorten the statute of limitations for IRS assessments of tax.
A U.S.-based executor may seek discharge from personal liability for estate, gift, or income taxes by filing IRS Form 5495 (Request for Discharge From Personal Liability Under Internal Revenue Code Section 2204 or 6905). The executor will be discharged from personal liability for any tax deficiency 9 months after the IRS’ receipt of the request for discharge or the earlier payment of any amount determined by the IRS to be owed.
Conclusion
The responsibilities of an executor extend far beyond asset management. U.S. tax laws impose a real and sometimes harsh risk of personal liability, particularly in cases involving unpaid estate taxes, where no knowledge of the liability is necessary for the executor’s personal liability to attach. For unpaid income or gift taxes, actual or constructive knowledge is required, but that offers little comfort to executors who fail to take precautionary steps. Executors should seek professional guidance, file the appropriate forms, and avoid premature distributions until all tax obligations have been conclusively settled.
Stay on top of tax matters around the globe.
Reach me at vljeker@us-taxes.org
Visit my US tax blog www.us-tax.org It is an invaluable guide in all areas of U.S. international tax. Stay on top of legislative developments and tax reform (including estate tax developments) and keep ahead of U.S. tax changes impacting your life, family or business.
NO ATTORNEY-CLIENT RELATIONSHIP OR LEGAL ADVICE
This communication is for general informational purposes only. It is not intended to constitute tax advice or a recommended course of action. Professional tax advice should be sought as the information here is not intended to be, and should not be, relied upon by the reader in making a decision.
Read the full article here
